Do You Make Judgments Without Context Or Facts? | “Mommy Wars”

Have you ever been appalled by a story someone told you about the behavior of a co-worker, or neighbor, or friend?

So appalled in fact that you shared the story with others (who were equally appalled) only to discover that when you heard all the facts – the context for said behavior – you realized the person’s behavior wasn’t horrible after all?

Does A Conviction For Rape Mean You’re A Rapist?

An example that dramatically highlights the importance of knowing context and all the facts, came from the movie a Time to Kill, based on the book by John Grisham.

Matthew McConaughey’s witness, a psychiatrist, was discredited by the prosecution because he had been convicted of rape 20+ years earlier, although the record had been expunged.

But as McConaughey explained in his closing argument:

” The truth has become lost….Let’s take Dr. Bass for example, obviously, I would have never knowingly put a convicted felon on the stand, I hope you can believe that…but what if I told you that the woman he was accused [by the girl's father]of raping  was 17 years old and he was 23 years old and she later became his wife and bore his child and she’s still married to the man today.”

Oops. Big oops.

As this example so clearly points out, you need to know the whole story before you start making judgments.

I know that.

I thought I’d learned that maxim well after making many mistakes throughout my life when I  had jumped to conclusions.

Well, I jumped to a conclusion yesterday and it’s biting me today.

TIME Magazine And The So-called “Mommy Wars”

Without reading the full TIME magazine cover story myself, I still supported an on-line petition to “stop media outlets from trying to fan the flames of a false, outdated ‘mommy war.’ ” It was a request to “get as many people as possible to contact TIME and hold the publishers accountable.”

I believe the media often tries to inflame its readership and have seen it happen previously with what they’ve coined as the “mommy wars” (obviously an incendiary phrase). So when I received a request to support holding TIME accountable, my bias took over my good sense.

I signed the letter although I’d only heard some comments and seen the cover (below) of Jamie Lynne Grumet breast-feeding her 3 year old son and read the annoying article title of ARE YOU MOM ENOUGH?

But today, at my local library, I read the whole article.

I don’t think the article was written in a way to purposely flame the fires of the so-called “mommy wars”.  It covered the history of Dr. Bill Sears, the “father” of attachment parenting and told the stories of women who follow this child-rearing practice to one degree or another.

To my way of thinking some of the mothers’ child rearing practices are extreme and I wouldn’t choose to follow them, if for no other reason than they would make me exhausted:

  • Not allowing a baby to cry at all – “attachment parenting dogma says that every baby’s whimper is a plea for help and that no infant should ever be left to cry.” (I believed in soothing my sons most of the time and never could stand letting them cry for too long. But sometimes I needed to get away from a crying baby held right next to my ear and stick a pillow over my head for silence).
  • Having the baby sleep in the parent’s bed or in a bassinet alongside the bed (I didn’t want my babies in bed with my husband and me for: 1. fear of rolling over on them and 2. I didn’t see the value in both my husband and I losing sleep when our sons awoke during the night since I had to be the one to get up because I was breastfeeding).
  • “Baby wearing” in which infants are literally attached to their mothers via slings. (I pretty much did my variation of this, although there weren’t slings then).

So yes, the article talked about the origin of child-rearing practices that not every mother follows but, again, I didn’t see the author blatantly flaming the fires of war. Therefore I would not have promoted that petition if I’d done my due diligence, as I should have if I am to support anything.

I am repentant and reminded again not to jump to conclusions or let my biases impact the study of new information.

It would be interesting to know if you feel that I’m flaming the “mommy wars” because I stated what my practices were and what my beliefs are.

It’s certainly not my intent to inflame or to criticize a method of child rearing that is different from mine.

I did what was right for me. You need to do what’s right for you. And some day our adult children will meet and probably like each other because they’ll all be good, responsible human beings.

How easy or difficult is it for you to accept another woman’s child-rearing practices that are different from your own?

 

 

Leaving Tiger Mom In The Dust – I’m Bear Mom

Bear Mom Testimonial #1

There was a lawyer I dated for a short time when my sons were young.

I didn’t realize how much I “showed” my Bear Mom side until a few months later when I called him for a referral for a friend who needed a lawyer for a custody battle he was in.

When I made the call apparently I never said the referral was for someone else. Mr. Esquire, thought I was in a custody battle with my ex-husband. He said he’d check with someone he knew and get back to me.

When he called me back he said that he’d spoken with Custody-Battle-Lawyer (CBL) and told Mr. CBL to expect a call from me.

picture from: www.firstpeople

“Oh. Sorry for the confusion, the referral isn’t for me, it’s for a friend.”

“Glad it’s not for you. I better call him back, though, because I told Mr. CBL to strap himself down, that you are one fierce Bear of a Mom and would not take this lying down.

How did he know that? It’s true but we’d never gone out together with my sons. I don’t think he even met them. Did I just exude that energy when I talked about Seth and Aaron?

Bear Mom Testimonial #2

It was a new school year. My older son was in 6th grade so attending middle school for the first time.

Everyday after school I’d ask him how things were.

“Fine.”

Loquacious is not a word I’d typically use to describe Seth.

So I was very surprised when I was talking to the mother of another 6th grader in the neighborhood, who also walked to school, and learned that a group of 7th graders were bullying and punching Seth, causing him to take different routes to school.

I was wild. And concerned. Why hadn’t Seth told me?

When Seth arrived home that day I told him what I’d heard and asked him if it was true.

“Yes.”

“Why didn’t you tell me?”

When I saw the look on his face, the reason hit me like a bolt of lightening.

“You were afraid that if you told me I’d drive the van through the front door of those kids’ houses and then pummel them in the face.”

My kid knew his Bear Mom well.

No one hurts my kids.

He remembered when I took on the abusive baseball coach who was calling – screaming really – the 6 & 7 year olds “pussy” if they didn’t swing at a pitch.

He knew I was fiercely protective of any small person who was being picked on by a bigger person.

He also knew, although I wouldn’t drive my van through the bullies’ doors, it would feel as if I had as I strode into the kids’ parents home to seethingly tell them what was going on.

So that was the day I learned, now that my kids were older, there were some battles I shouldn’t protect them from.

Or, as Seth and I agreed, he’d handle the bullying his way unless it became worse.

It wasn’t easy for me not to growl at the bullies and their parents, but Seth believed I’d make the situation worse for him.

This happened 20 years ago. With all the articles about bullying and suicide, I don’t know what I’d do today.

Hey moms, what do you think? What would you do?

HAPPY MOTHER’S DAY. Thanks for being best mom you can be!

 

Coming of Age at 62 | Why I still need to be given Pitocin to induce contractions

Jayne Mansfield via Flickr by MsBlueSky

 

What you see in a mirror depends on so many things.

Are you looking at your reflection under sunlight or the gloom that can come at the end of the day, when the sun is setting?

Are you looking straight on or standing a bit to the left and only seeing a partial image of what is you?

Is what you’re seeing distorted by the shape of the mirror you choose?

Are you taking a 360 degree look at yourself and seeing all of what is you?

What Others See

In a salon after getting your hair cut, you gain a different perspective of your new ‘do when the stylist holds up the mirror so you can see how you look to the people whose only view of you will be when walking behind you.

You need to understand those views too, because too often your viewpoint of yourself is narrow or distorted or almost blinded by years of limited beliefs.

<sigh>

Yep, this is really a story about me.

I’m working with a coach to help me get to the next level in my business.

Unfortunately (and fortunately) part of that process is holding up a mirror to my actions. A mirror constructed of questions for me to answer. To ponder.

Fuck.  I know coming of age, again, means learning new things about yourself. Or re-learning lessons that didn’t stick. And this is a normal part of continuing to learn and  grow. Most days I like learning…love it in fact. But today – not so much. That’s because I know this is only the beginning of 6 months of a full body, surround-sound Question Mark Mirror being held up to me.

Her most recent question was:

What “story” or belief came up for you that made you hold back in enrolling [a potential client] more assertively?

Rationalization (said VERY LOUDLY IN MY HEAD): “I didn’t want to! She was crying. She was in pain. She would have to take money out of her savings.”

Truth: “I lost my confidence because I couldn’t guarantee that she would be saved from all her pain and problems.”

What I Need To Remember: Childbirth Hurts But It’s So Worth It

More truth: I’m stuck at 7 meters dilated and 60% effaced in “up-leveling” my business.

My coach is giving me Pitocin to induce contractions and get things moving.

That’s what I’d do with one of my clients, but agreeing with her delivery methods doesn’t reduce the pain. Not one bit.

I have to remember that the last time I was given Pitocin I ended up with a healthy, wonderful new life to hold, enjoy and love. <deep breath> It will happen again.

Once I go though all these induced labor pains I’m going to again deliver something very special – a new, even stronger, more joyful version of me.

I’d love to hear: What was the “Pitocin” that helped you take the next step toward what you want in your life?